1859 Mutual

In the narrative of our growth, Pike Mutual has penned a new chapter, merging with Woodville Mutual, and rebranding as 1859 Mutual. For a glimpse into the next pages of our story, you’re invited to continue the journey with us at our new website. https://1859mutual.com

We love our independent agents! Their diligent work on behalf of our members helps individuals, families, and businesses get the right type of policy for their specific needs. We have the utmost confidence in their abilities and expertise. Of course, it can give policyholders even more confidence when they know more about their agent. With that in mind, here is a profile of the Andrews-Kemp Insurance Agency.

After seven years teaching vocational agriculture and another seven years working as a loan officer, Tom Andrews began his own insurance agency in July 1987, offering home, life, and health insurance. The Andrews Agency soon partnered with Pike Mutual, becoming one of our representatives in 1989.

In the late 1990s, the Andrews Agency became affiliated with Kemp Insurance Agency in New Philadelphia, Ohio, founded by Don Kemp. This affiliation has continued to grow over the years, as shown by Don’s son Nathan joining the agencies in 2009. Today, Andrews-Kemp Insurance Agency serves the insurance needs of homeowners, farm owners, and small business owners in Tuscarawas County and the surrounding area.

With over 30 years working together, we look forward to many more years in partnership with the Andrews-Kemp Insurance Agency! We know that the client-first approach offered by our independent agents can make such a big difference for our members.